Reid Coploff of the Penn State Collegian reviewed The White Stripes new album ‘Elephant’. He writes, “Through 14 tracks, Jack and Meg provide different twists on their celebrated sound. The album is probably not going to win the band any new fans. And it absolutely, unequivocally does not deserve the five-star review bestowed upon it by Rolling Stone.” He added, “What makes Elephant stand out is that, remarkably, the band somehow managed to produce the same rugged, under-produced sound it had on its independent releases.”
The story at collegian.psu.edu has since been removed.